The short answer: Old Wisconsin Beef Sticks are a smaller serving, with 3g protein, 0g carbs and 200mg sodium per serving. Trail's Best Beef Sticks and Buffalo Bills Mild Ole' Smokies are larger sticks with 6g protein each. Because the sizes differ, compare by the ounce, not by the stick.
Side by side
| Old Wisconsin Beef Sticks | Trail's Best Beef Stick | Buffalo Bills Mild Ole' Smokies | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Serving | About 0.57 oz (14 servings per 8 oz pack) | 1 stick (1.1 oz) | 1 stick (0.7 oz) |
| Meat | Beef | Beef | Beef |
| Protein | 3g | 6g | 6g |
| Carbs | 0g | <1g | 1g |
| Sodium | 200mg | 360mg | 345mg |
Old Wisconsin figures are from a grocery store listing for the 8 oz pack, checked in November 2026. The listing did not show a serving weight, so the size above is the pack weight divided by its 14 servings. Ours are from the package labels. Check the package for current values.
What is different
- Size: Old Wisconsin servings are the smallest of the three. Trail's Best is the largest stick at 1.1 oz.
- Protein: 6g per stick for Trail's Best and Ole' Smokies, 3g per Old Wisconsin serving.
- Carbs: all three list 1g or less.
Which should you pick?
- Small bites from the grocery store: Old Wisconsin.
- Small sticks by the bag: Buffalo Bills Short Shots and other mini sticks.
- A full size stick: Trail's Best Beef Sticks or Buffalo Bills Ole' Smokies.
- A Pennsylvania classic: Lebanon Bologna Sticks.
More comparisons: Beef Sticks vs Slim Jim, Best Beef Sticks and What Is a Beef Stick?
Common questions
How do Old Wisconsin Beef Sticks compare with other beef sticks?
Old Wisconsin Beef Sticks list 3g protein, 0g carbs and 200mg sodium per serving, with 14 servings in an 8 oz pack. Trail's Best Beef Sticks and Buffalo Bills Mild Ole' Smokies are larger and list 6g protein per stick.
Which beef stick has the most protein per stick?
Among these three, Trail's Best Beef Sticks and Buffalo Bills Mild Ole' Smokies list 6g per stick, and Old Wisconsin lists 3g per serving. Serving sizes differ.
Where can I buy mini beef sticks online?
Beefsticks.com sells Buffalo Bills Short Shots and other mini sticks in bulk bags, with free shipping on orders of $59 or more in the mainland US.
Old Wisconsin is a trademark of its owner. Beefsticks.com is not affiliated with or endorsed by the maker of Old Wisconsin.

